Incorporating the Ecological, Socio-economic and Institutional Conceptual Model Framework for Sustainable Management of Small-scale Mud Crab (Scylla serrata) Fishery in Western Seram Regency, Indonesia 10.32526/ennrj/19/2020189
Article Sidebar
Main Article Content
Abstract
Mud crab Scylla serrata of Kotania Bay and Pelita Jaya Bay of Western Seram District, has been harvested by local fishermen for more than 25 years. The mud crab has high economic value, and there is always a market for this fishery. The economic dependence of the fishermen forces them to harvest this resource extensively. No existing management strategy and extensive exploitation leads to unsustainable conditions of this fishery. With inadequate data condition, the Driver-Pressure-State-Impact-Response (DPSIR) model constructs an ecological, social-economy, and institutional conceptual model framework for sustainable management of this fishery. The driving force (D) in this fishery comes from the local fishers harvesting the mud crab. The two most sensitive attributes that affected mud crab sustainability from Rapfish analysis were used as state-level of DPSIR methodology. The result shows that the most sensitive variables from ecological, socio-economy, and institution were: caught before maturity, mud crab size, consumer attitude towards sustainability, just management, government quality, and monitoring and reporting, respectively. It was concluded that this conceptual model allows a better understanding of how the mud crab S. serrata system works and management actions taken at different system components. This conceptual model framework can be a useful tool to incorporate the participation of stakeholders, managers, and scientists in the process of a sustainable management plan.
Article Details
Published articles are under the copyright of the Environment and Natural Resources Journal effective when the article is accepted for publication thus granting Environment and Natural Resources Journal all rights for the work so that both parties may be protected from the consequences of unauthorized use. Partially or totally publication of an article elsewhere is possible only after the consent from the editors.
References
Angel E, Edwards DN, Hawkshaw S, Wor C, Parlee CE. An indicator framework to support comprehensive approaches to sustainable fisheries management. Ecology and Society 2019;24(4):1-34.
Aquino JIL. Promoting responsible aquaculture for the sustainable production of soft-shell crabs. Fish and People 2018;10(3): 46-51.
Balzan MV, Pinheiro AM, Mascarenhas A, Morán-Ordóñez A, Ruiz-Frau A, Carvalho-Santos C, et al. Improving ecosystem assessments in Mediterranean social-ecological systems: DPSIR analysis. Ecosystem and People 2019;15(1):136-55.
Barclay K, Michelle V, Mazur N, Payne, AN, Mauli S, Kinh J, et al. The importance of qualitative social research for effective fisheries management. Fisheries Research 2017;186(2):426-38.
Chap S, Meng K, Tep C, Joffre O. Crab Fisheries in Cambodia and the Development of Crab Banks. Phnom Penh, Cambodia: The Learning Institute and the World Fish Centre; 2012.
Courtney CA, Pomeroy R, De Alessi M, Adhuri D, Yuni C, Halim A. Marine tenure and small-scale fisheries: Learning from the Indonesia experience. Washington, DC: USAID Tenure and Global Climate Change Program and USAID Indonesia Sustainable Ecosystems Advanced Project; 2017.
Dambacher JM, Gaughan DJ, Rochet MJ, Rossignol PA, Trenkel VM. Qualitative modelling and indicators of exploited ecosystems. Fish and Fisheries 2009;10(3):305-22.
Department of Agiculture and Fisheries (DAF). Queensland Sustainable fisheries Strategy 2017-2027 [Internet]. 2017 [cited 2020 Aug 20]. Available from: https://cabinet.qld.gov. au/documents/2017/Jun/FishPol/Attachments/Strategy.pdf.
Díaz ME, Figueroa R, Alonso MLS, Vidal-Abarca MR. Exploring the complex relations between water resources and social indicators: The Biobío Basin (Chile). Ecosystem Service 2018;31:84-92.
Diekert FK. Growth overfishing: The race to fish extends to the dimension of size. Environmental and Resource Economics 2012;52:549-72.
Elliot M, Burdon D, Atkins JP, Borja A, Cormier M, de Jonge VN, et al. “And DPSIR begat DPSI(W)R(M)!”-A unifying framework for marine environmental management. Marine Pollution Bulletin 2017;118(1-2):27-40.
Foley P, Okyere DA, Mather C. Alternative environmentalities: Recasting the assessment of Canada’s first Marine Stewardship Council-certified fishery in social terms. Ecology and Society 2018;23(3):37(1-10).
Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO). Workshop on Toolbox for the Ecosystem Approach to fisheries. FAO Fisheries and Aquaculture Report. Nr. 884. FIFM/R884(En) [Internet]. 2008 [cited 2020 Jan 20]. Available from: http://www.fao.org/ tempref/docrep/fao/012/i0946e/i0946e.pdf.
Fortnam MP. Forces opposing sustainability transformations: Institutionalization of ecosystem-based approaches to fisheries management. Ecology and Society 2019;24(4):33(1-15).
Froese R. Keep it simple: Three indicators to deal with overfishing. Fish and Fisheries 2004;5:86-91.
Fujita R, Cusack C, Karasik R, Takade-Heumacher H, Baker C. Technologies for Improving Fisheries Monitoring. San Fransisco, USA: Environmental Defense Fund; 2018.
Gari SR, Newton A, Icely JD. A review of the application and evolution of the DPSIR framework with an emphasis on coastal social-ecological systems. Ocean and Coastal Management 2015;103:63-77.
Gebremedhin S, Getahun A, Anteneh W, Bruneel S, Goethals P. A drivers-pressure-state-impact-responses framework to support the sustainability of fish and fisheries in Lake Tana, Ethiopia. Sustainability 2018;10(8):1-20.
Gough CLA, Dewar KM, Godley BJ, Zafindranosy E, Broderick AC. Evidence of overfishing in small-scale fisheries in Madagascar. Frontiers in Marine Science 2020;7:1-17.
Grubert MA, Walters CJ, Brown RC, Penny SS. Simple modeling to inform harvest strategy policy for a data-moderate crab fishery. Marine and Coastal Fisheries: Dynamics, Management, and Ecosystem Science 2019;11(2):125-38.
Harvey CJ, Reum JC, M. Poe MR, Williams GD, Kim SJ. Using conceptual models and qualitative network models to advance integrative assessments of marine ecosystems. Coastal Management 2016;44(5):486-503.
Huliselan NV, Wawo M, Tuapattinaja MA, Sahetapy D. Present status of grouper fisheries at waters of Kotania Bay, Western Seram Regency Maluku Province. IOP Conference Series Earth and Environmental Science 2017;89(1):012002.
Ingram RJ, Oleson KL, Gove JM. Revealing complex social-ecological interactions through participatory modeling to support ecosystem-based management in Hawai'i. Marine Policy 2018;94:180-8.
Jirapunpipat K. Population structure at size of maturity of the orange mud crab Scylla olivacea in Klong Ngao mangrove swamp, Ranong Province, Thailand Kasetsart Journal: Natural Science 2008;42(1):31-40.
Jöhl A. Crab Banks: A Literature Review. Bangkok, Thailand: IUCN; 2013.
Karim MY, Azis HY, Muslimin, Tahya AM. Physiological response: survival, growth, and nutrient content of the mud crabs (Scylla olivacea) which cultivated in mangrove area with different types of feed. AACL Bioflux 2017;10(5):1534-9.
Kavanagh P, Pitcher TJ. Implementing Microsoft Excel Software for Rapfish: A Technique for the Rapid Appraisal of Fisheries Status. Vancouver, Canada: University of British Columbia Fisheries Centre Research; 2004.
Keenan CP. The fourth species of Scylla. In: Keenan CP, Blackshaw A, editors. Proceedings of an International Scientific Forum; 1997 Apr 21-24; ACIAR Proceedings No. 78, Darwin: Australia; 1999. p. 48-58.
Kelble CR, Loomis DK, Lovelace S, Nuttle WK, Peter Ortner PB, Fletcher P, et al. The EBM-DPSER conceptual model: Integrating ecosystem services into the DPSIR framework. PLOS ONE 2013;8(8):e70766.
Kell LT, Luckhurst BE. Extending the indicator-based ecosystem report card to the whole ecosystem: A preliminary example based on the Sargasso Sea. Collective Volumes of Scientific Paper ICCAT 2018;75(2):258-75.
Khoa TND, Harrison FS. Development of mud crab breeding technology for conservation and communal livelihoods in the Setiu Wetlands, Terengganu, Malaysia. Asian Journal of Agriculture and Biology 2019;Special Issue:11-6.
Kvamsdal SF, Eide A, Ekerhovd A, Enberg K, Gudmundsdottir A, Hoel AH, et al. Harvest control rules in modern fisheries management. Elementa: Science of the Anthropocence 2016;4:1-22.
Liu W, Sun C, Zhao M, Wu Y. Application of a DPSIR modelling framework to assess spatial-temporal differences of water poverty in China. Journal of the American Water Resources Association 2019;55(1):259-73.
Marine Stewardship Council (MSC). Monitoring and evaluation framework. Certified Sustainable Seafood [Internet]. 2019 [cited 2020 Aug 19]. Available from: https://www.msc.org/ what-we-are-doing/our-collective-impact/monitoring-and-evaluating.
Martin DM, Piscopo AN, Chintala MM, Gleason TR, Berry W. Developing qualitative ecosystem service relationships with the Driver-Pressure-State-Impact-Response framework: A case study on Cape Cod, Massachusetts. Ecology Indicator 2018;84:404-15.
Ministry of Marine Affairs and Fisheries (MMAF), Republic of Indonesia, and USAID Sustainable Ecosystems Advanced (SEA) Project. State of the Sea: Indonesia, Volume One: An Overview of Marine Resource Management for Small-Scale Fisheries and Critical Marine Habitats in Indonesia. Jakarta, Indonesia; 2018.
Mozumder MMH, Phyla A, Wahab MdA, Darkki S, Schneider P, Islam MM. Understanding social-ecological challenges of a small-scale Hilsa (Tenualosa ilisha) fishery in Bangladesh. International Journal of Environment Research and Public Health 2019;16:1-24.
Natan Y. Fattening of small mud crab Scylla serrata harvested by local fisher from Wael Village, Sub-Regency Piru, Western Seram Regency. Jurnal Perikanan (Journal of Fisheries Science) 2014;15(2):79-87 (in Indonesian).
Ordines F, Lloret J, Tugores P, Manfredi C, Guijarro B, Jadaud A, et al. A new approach to recruitment overfishing diagnosis based on fish condition from survey data. Scientia Marina 2019;83S1:223-33.
Pauly D. From growth to malthusian overfishing: Stages of fisheries resources misuse. SPC Traditional Marine Resource Management and Knowledge Information Bulletin 1994;3:7-14.
Pauly D, Zeller D. The best catch data that can possibly be? Rejoinder to Ye et al. “FAO's statistic data and sustainability of fisheries and aquaculture. Marine Policy 2017;81:406-10.
Patrício J, Elliott M, Mazik K, Papadopoulou KN, Smith CJ. DPSIR-Two Decades of trying to develop a unifying framework for marine environmental management. Frontiers in Marine Science 2016;3:177(1-14).
Persada NPR, Fachrudin M, Mangujjaya, Tobing ISL. Sasi as a natural conservation culture in Maluku Islands. Jurnal Ilmu dan Budaya 2018;41(59):6869-900 (in Indonesia).
PEW Charitable Trusts. Management strategy evaluation for fisheries: Informing the selection of harvest strategies [Internet]. 2016 [cited 2020 Jan 20]. Available from: https://www.pewtrusts.org/-/media/assets/2019/07/harvest-strategies/hs_mse_update. pdf.
Pitcher TJ, Kalikoski D, Short K, Varkey D, Pramoda G. An evaluation of progress in implementing ecosystem-based management of fisheries in 33 countries. Marine Policy 2009;33:223-32.
Pitcher TJ, Lam ME, Ainsworth C, Martindale A, Nakamura K, Perry RI, et al. Improvements to Rapfish: A rapid evaluation technique for fisheries integrating ecological and human dimensions. Journal of Fish Biology 2013;83:865-89.
Pitcher TJ, Preikshot D. RAPFISH; A rapid appraisal technique to evaluate sustainability status of fisheries. Fisheries Research 2001;49:255-70.
Plaganyi EE. Models for an Ecosystem Approach to Fisheries. FAO Fisheries Technical Papers No. 477. Rome, Italy: FAO; 2007.
Quimby B, Levine A. Participation, power, and equity: Examining three key social dimensions of fisheries comanagement. Sustainability 2018;10:3324(1-20).
Rapfish Group. Standard Attributes for Rapfish Analysis: Evaluation Fields for Ecological, Technological, Economic, Social, and Ethical Status. Vancouver, Canada: Fisheries Centre, University of British Columbia; 2006.
Rosellon-Druker J, Szymkowiak M, Cunningham CJ, Kasperski S, Kruse GH, Moss JH, et al. Development of social-ecological conceptual models as the basis for an integrated ecosystem assessment framework in Southeast Alaska. Ecology and Society 2019;24(3):30(1-18).
Salehi E, Zebardast L. Applicatin of driving force-pressure-state-impact-respones (DPSIR) framework for integrated environmental assessment of the cliamte change in city of Teheran. Pollution 2016;2(1):83-92.
Shelley C. Capture-based aquaculture of mud crabs (Scylla spp.). In: Lovatelli A, Holthus PF, editors. Capture-based Aquaculture: Global Overview. FAO Fisheries Technical Paper. No. 508. Rome, Italy: FAO; 2008. p. 255-69.
Siahainenia L, Natan Y, Khouw AS, Pattikawa JA. Size distribution, growth pattern and condition factor of mangrove crab Scylla serrata in the coastal waters of Western Seram, Maluku, Indonesia. International Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Studies 2016;4(2):291-6.
Smith C, Papadopoulou N, Barnard S, Mazik K, Patrício J, Elliott M, et al. Conceptual Mmodels for the Effects of Marine Pressures on Biodiversity. DEVOTES Deliverable; 2014. p. 82.
Smith H, Basurto X. Defining small-scale fisheries and examining the role of science in shaping perceptions of who and what counts: A systematic review. Frontiers in Marine Science 2019;6:236(1-19).
Sobocinski KL, Greene CM, Schmidt MW. Using a qualitative model to explore the impacts of ecosystem and anthropogenic drivers upon declining marine survival in Pacific salmon. Environmental Conservation 2017:45(3):278-90.
Soselisa HL. Sasi Lompa: A critical review of the contribution of local practices to sustainable marine resource management in Central Maluku, Indonesia. IOP Conference Series Earth and Environmental Science 2019;339:012013.
Staples D, Brainard R, Capezzuoli S, Funge-Smith S, Grose C, Heenan A, et al. Essential EAFM: Ecosystem Approach to Fisheries Management Training Course. Volume 1-For Trainees. FAO Regional Office for Asia and the Pacific. Bangkok, Thailand: RAP Publication; 2014.
Stephenson RL, Paul S, Wiber M, Angel E, Benson AJ, Charles A, et al. Evaluating and implementing social-ecological systems: A comprehensive approach to sustainable fisheries. Fish and Fisheries 2018;19(5):853-73.
Tetelepta JMS, Makatita M. An approach to the management of mud crab Scylla serrata through the reproductive status of mud crab and socio economy and institutional aspects of the fishermen at Pelita Jaya, Western Seram Regency. Triton Jurnal Manajemen Sumberdaya Perairan 2012;8(1):1-11.
Tetelepta JMS, Khouw AS, Natan Y, Ongkers OTS. Some biological aspects of mud crab Scylla serrata (Forskal) Fisheries in Pelita Jaya Bay, Western Seram Regency Indonesia. International Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Studies 2017;5(5):272-7.
Tetelepta JMS, Natan Y, Ongkers OTS, Pattikawa JA. Some population biology aspects of edible orange mud crab Scylla olivacea (Herbst, 1796) of Kotania Bay, Western Seram Regency, Indonesia. AACL Bioflux 2018;11(4):1203-12.
Tetelepta JMS, Natan Y, Pattikawa JA, Pattisina BJ. Fishery of mud crab Scylla serrata of Kotania Bay, Western Seram Regency: potency, stock status and sustainable management. IOP Journal Series: Earth and Environmental Science 2019;339:012002.
Thiammueang D, Chuenpagdee R, Juntarashote K. The crab bank project: Lessons from the voluntary fishery conservation initiative in Phetchaburi Province, Thailand. Kasetsart Journal: Natural Science 2012;46:427-39.
Thorpe RB, De Oliveira JAA. Comparing conceptual frameworks for a fish community MSY (FCMSY) using management strategy evaluation-an example from the North Sea. ICES Journal of Marine Science 2019;76(4):813-23.
Tilley A, Hunnam KJ, Mills DJ, Steenbergen DJ, Govan H, Alonso-Poblacion E, et al. Evaluating the fit of co-management for small-scale fisheries governance in Timor Leste. Frontiers in Marine Science 2019;6:392(1-17).
Voyer MA, Barclay K, Mazur N. Using a well-being approach to develop a framework for an integrated socio-economic evaluation of professional fishing. Fish and Fisheries 2017;18(6):1134-49.
Waithaka E, Boera P, Obegi B, Mutie A, Morara G, Loki P, et al. The impacts of co-management towards sustainable development and utilization of fisheries resources in Lake Naivasha, Kenya. Poultry, Fisheries and Wildlife Sciences 2020;8(1):1-6.
Warawarin CY, Cangara H, Muhadar. The symbolic comunication denoting of sasi traditional law in marine conservation in Southeasr Maluku District. Jurnal Komunikasi KAREBA 2017;6(1):19 (in Indonesian).
Wouthuyzen S, Sapulete D. Condition of coastal area of Western Seram past and present: A review. Perairan Maluku dan Sekitarnya 1994;7:1-18 (in Indonesian).
Yi S. Determinants of consumers’ purchasing behavior for certified aquaculture products in South Korea. Sustainability 2019;11:3840(1-18).
Zador GZ, Gaichas SK, Kasperski S, Ward CL, Blake RE, Ban NC, et al. Linking ecosystem processes to communities of practice through commercially fished species in the Gulf of Alaska. ICES Journal of Marine Science 2017;74(7):2024-33.
Zander K, Feucht Y. Consumers’ willingness to pay for sustainable seafood made in Europe. Journal of International Food and Agribusiness Marketing 2018;30(3):251-75.