Elasto-plastic deformation analysis of A1050P aluminum sheet subjected to three-point bending and estimation of the springback of the bent sheet

Main Article Content

Weerayut Jina
Sungkom Srisomporn
Rungtawee Padakan
Arthit Sangngam
Patchara Wongthong
Montri Sangsuriyun

Abstract

This study describes the three-point bending deformation characteristics of the bent part of an aluminum alloy sheet (A1050P). The elasto-plastic states in the bent zone of the worksheet at bending angles of 0°–90° were simulated using the finite element method (FEM). To develop a simulation bending model, a three-point bending experiment was conducted using a 0.39-mm-thick aluminum sheet. The bending load resistance and deformation profile of the bent part in the FEM model were compared with the experimental results, and the initial punch indentation depth (dP) was varied within a certain range. The FEM model was developed and simulated using isotropic elasto-plastic solid properties. When simulating the three-point bending process, the modification of the plastic coefficient appears to be the primary characteristic that closely matches the experimental results. Through the FEM simulation of the worksheet, the following results were obtained: (1) The contract friction force (c) between the worksheet and the channel die was greater than that between the punch and the worksheet. This may be due to the boundary conditions of the three-point bending apparatus. (2) The pressure dependency of the friction coefficient is important. Further investigation into this pressure dependency, specifically the relationship between contact pressure and frictional resistance, should be considered. (3) The corner radius of the channel dies had a greater impact on the maximum principal compressive stress (P2max) than the maximum principal tensile stress (P1max), primarily because of the abrasive forces encountered during the three-point bending process. The peak maximum ratio of   P2max by P1max was approximately 1.12–1.27. An appropriate round edge of the corner die is important. (4) The number of nonlinear elasto-plastic states at the bending zone appeared to be three. The different separations in the three states may be due to the three different stress distribution patterns. (5) Regarding springback, for large (deep) deformations, Gardiner’s model closely matched the simulation model. This was confirmed by comparing the undefined V-notch with the applied V-notch. However, for small (shallow) deformations, further investigation is required through experimentations.

Article Details

Section
บทความวิจัย (Research Article)

References

Sun B, Liu R, Gu B. Numerical simulation of three-point bending fatigue of four-step 3-D braided rectangular composite under different stress levels from unit-cell approach. Computational Materials Science. 2012;65: 239-246.

Li A, Zhao J, Wang D, Gao X, Tang H. Three-point bending fatigue behavior of WC – Co cemented carbides. Materials and Design. 2013;45: 271-278.

Srinivasan R, Karthik Raja G. Experimental study on bending behaviour of aluminium-copper clad sheets in V-bending process. Mechanics & Industry. 2019;20(6): 1-8.

Bakhshivash S, Sadeghi BM, Rahimi F, Haghshenas M. Effect of bending angle and punch tip radius on spring-forward in an Al- Mg-Si Alloy. International Mineral Processing Congress, 11-15 Sep 2016, Quebec, Canada. 2016. p.1-10.

Ghimire S, Emeerith Y, Ghosh R, Ghosh S. Finite element analysis of an aluminium alloy sheet in a V-Die punch mechanism considering spring- back effect. International Journal of Theoretical and Applied Mechanics. 2017;12(2): 331-342.

Maati A, Tabourot L, Balland P, Belaid S. Influence of the material microstructural properties on a 3-point bending test. Mechanics & Industry. 2020;21(518): 1-9.

Yue Z, Qi J, Zhao X, Badreddine H, Gao J, Chu X. Springback prediction of aluminum alloy sheet under changing loading paths with consideration of the influence of kinematic hardening and ductile damage. Metals. 2018;8(11): 1-14.

Salem C Ben, Meslameni W. A Numerical investigation on the springback in air v-bending of aluminum 1050 A. International Journal of Research in Industrial Engineering. 2022;11(2): 119–133.

Mitsomwang P, Borrisutthekul R, Klaiw-awoot K, Pattalung A. Experimental and numerical investigations of applying tip-bottomed tool for bending advanced ultra-high strength steel sheet. 2nd International Conference on Advanced Materials Research and Manufacturing Technologies (AMRMT 2017), 2-5 Aug 2017, Phuket, Thailand. Thailand: Institute of Physics Publishing; 2017. p.1-12.

Cruz DJ, Barbosa MR, Santos AD, Miranda SS, Amaral RL. Application of machine learning to bending processes and material identification. Metals. 2021;11(1418): 1-24.

Esat V, Darendeliler H, Gokler MI. Finite element analysis of springback in bending of aluminium sheets. Materials and Design. 2002;23(2): 223-229.

Saravanan S, Saravanan M, Jeyasimman D. Study on effects of spring back on sheet metal bending using simulation methods. International Journal of Mechanical and Production Engineering Research and Development. 2018;8(2): 923-932.

Aday AJ. Analysis of springback behavior in steel and aluminum sheets using FEM. Annales de Chimie - Science des Matériaux. 2019;43(2): 95-98.

Shu JS, Hung C. Finite element analysis and optimization of springback reduction: The “Double-Bend” technique. International Journal of Machine Tools and Manufacture. 1996;36(4): 423-434.

Dizaji SA, Darendeliler H, Kaftanoğlu B. Effect of hardening models on different ductile fracture criteria in sheet metal forming. International Journal of Material Forming. 2016;9: 261-267.

Gattmah J, Taha M, Shihab SK. Sheet metal forming processes for various materials using finite element analysis. 1st International Conference on Advances in Mechanical and Mechatronics Engineering, 8-9 Nov 2018, Ankara, Turkey. 2018. p.369-376.

Kartik T, Rajesh R. Effect of punch radius and sheet thickness on spring-back in V-die bending. Advances in Natural and Applied Sciences. 2017;11(8): 178-183.

Aljibori HSS, Hamouda AM. Finite element analysis of sheet metal forming process. European Journal of Scientific Research. 2009;33(1): 57-69.

Thuillier S, Le Maoût N, Manach PY. Bending limit prediction of an aluminum thin sheet. International Journal of Material Forming. 2010;3(1): 223-226.

Wagner L, Larour P, Dolzer D, Leomann F, Suppan C. Experimental issues in the instrumented 3 point bending VDA238-100 test. International Deep-Drawing Research Group (IDDRG 2020), 26-30 Oct 2020, Seoul, South Korea. IOP Publishing Ltd; 2020. p.1-11.

Hou P, Zhao H, Ma Z, Zhang S, Li J, Dong X, et al. Influence of punch radius on elastic modulus of three-point bending tests. Advances in Mechanical Engineering. 2016;8(5): 1-8.

Murayama M, Nagasawa S, Fukuzawa Y, Katayama I. Effect of sheet thickness and friction on load characteristic of crushed center bevel cutter indented to aluminum sheet. In: Brebbia C.A. (ed.) Computational Methods in Contact Mechanics VI. Southampton, England; WIT Press; 2003. p. 115-124.

Murayama M, Nagasawa S, Fukuzawa Y, Katayama I. Cutting mechanism and load characteristic of trapezoidal center bevel cutter indented on aluminum sheet. JSME International Journal, Series C: Mechanical Systems, Machine Elements and Manufacturing. 2004;47(1): 21-28.

Chaijit S, Nagasawa S, Fukuzawa Y, Murayama M, Katayama I. Effect of tip profile on cutting processability of a trapezoidal cutting blade indented to an aluminum sheet. Journal of Mechanics of Materials and Structures. 2006;1(8): 1301-1321.

Chaijit S, Nagasawa S. FEM simulation on sensitivity of crack propagation on aluminum sheet during wedge shearing process. Proceedings of International Conference on Leading Edge Manufacturing in 21st Century: LEM21, 2-4 Dec 2009, Osaka, Japan. The Japan Society of Mechanical Engineers: 2009. p.379-384.

Ould Ouali M, Aberkane M. Micromechanical modeling of the rolling of a A1050P aluminum sheet. International Journal of Material Forming. 2009;2(1): 1-18.

Chakravarty P, Pál G, Bátorfi JG, Sidor JJ. Estimation of dislocation distribution at mid thickness for 1050 Al. Acta Materialia Transylvanica. 2022;5(1): 6-9.

Jina W, Thanomputra S, Sangsuriyun M, Nagasawa S. Finite element simulation of bending process under three-point bending test of aluminum sheet. The 4th SEITS Conference 2022 and Exhibition on Sufficiency Economy of Engineering, Innovation and Technological Development towards Leadership for Sustainability, 5-6 Sep 2022, Bangkok, Thailand. Kasem Bundit University; 2022. p.66-72.

ASTM International. ASTM D790-3, Standard Test Methods for Flexural Properties of Unreinforced and Reinforced Plastics and Electrical Insulating Materials, American Society for Testing and Materials. West Conshohocken; 2003.

MSC Software. Marc document: Theory and User Information. 2014;A: p. 790-791.

Wang J, Verma S, Alexander R, Gau JT. Springback control of sheet metal air bending process. Journal of Manufacturing Processes. 2008;10(1): 21-27.